No Pageant for You, French Girls!

Beauty pageant girlThe French Senate has just taken the first step in banning beauty pageants for girls under the age of 16.  Right away, I want to ask why this is the hot topic du jour? When did beauty pageants take central stage?  First, it was the recent selection of a bright, talented young woman with a degree from the University of Michigan as Miss America 2014 and now France, of all places, has is leaning toward making pageants for very young girls a crime punishable by a fine and two years in jail.

Why am I interested in any of this?

I’m a pageant mom.

It was bound to come out sooner or later.  I spent many hours and many dollars taking my daughter from pageant to pageant when she was in high school.  In full disclosure, I loved every minute of it.  We both had a wonderful time.  I’ve been watching beauty pageants since I was a kid and I can admit freely that we watch Toddlers and Tiaras, although I draw the line at Honey Boo-Boo.  Even though I could not speak about all the pageants that run on any given weekend, certainly criminalizing beauty pageants is wrong-headed and the scrutiny is misdirected in many ways.

French beauty pageant ban proponent Chantal Jouanno was quoted recently in the New York Times, saying that having children look to external standards of beauty is “extremely destructive.”  She wants young girls to be judged by their intellect instead.  Remarkably, she and others believe that this ban, which is part of a larger bill establishing standards for gender equality, will make a stand for young women.

I would agree with the ban on pageants for children if pageant entry were either mandatory or pervasive.  But in the whole time my daughter and I were on the pageant circuit, we did not meet one other person we knew previously and, more importantly, we met the same dozen girls over and over again.  In New York State, at least, it’s the same girls who cycle through all the pageants until they either win, lose too often and get discouraged, or age out of the competition.  While I realize that is not the case everywhere, I think if you took an average of how many girls compete, it’s probably a very small number in any given pageant season.

Nobody wants children harmed by any of the assortment of things grown-ups throw at them —  scheduling too many after-school activities, offering too little time to play outdoors, stockpiling too many video games, wearing make-up too soon, having cell phones or free access to the Internet at a young age; any number of these assaults on childhood will have a lasting impact.  But you can’t will a simpler age into existence any more than you can keep children from experiencing their own lives.  Banning children’s pageants won’t stop these girls from growing up in a world that wants them not only to be really smart and competitive, but also, really pretty.

I do, though, wish that the parents we see on Toddlers and Tiaras would stop using their children as a meal ticket to fame and fortune.  If only they’d take a step back sometimes and listen to the way their TV kids are howling after being dragged into one more hotel room with their “flippers” and their wigs and spray-on tans.

Aside from the reality show versions of young beauty queen life, I just don’t see this level of pageants as harmful if it teaches girls that dressing up can win competitions.  Based on my experience, and that of my daughter, dressing up for a walk on the runway is so much more like Halloween than anything that is long-lasting.  Ultimately, these pageants are not reinforcing an old 1950’s stereotype of some brainless twit who thinks math is for boys.  What most of the judging talks about, in this country at least, is confidence.  What level of confidence does the contestant display?  How comfortable are they on stage?  Do they make eye contact with the judges?  That’s not terrible or harmful.  If anything, that’s a good thing.

If you want to ban something that is really harmful to young children, couldn’t we please start with football?

Anne Born is a New York-based writer who has been writing stories and poetry since childhood.  While her children were enrolled in New York City public schools in the late 1990s, she edited and published The Backpack Press, and the CSDIII News, a monthly newsletter covering all public schools on Manhattan’s Upper West Side.  She blogs on Open Salon and Red Room and her writing focuses on family and life in a big city after growing up in a small one.  She is also a photographer who specializes in photos of churches, cemeteries, and the Way of St. James in Spain.  Most of her writing is done on the bus.  www.about.me/anneborn. You can follow Anne on Twitter at @nilesite.

 Image via iStockphoto/Judy Kennamer

  • http://phdinparenting.com Annie @ PhD in Parenting

    I’m pretty sure that American-style football isn’t a regular activity for French children. They play “football”, which is what North Americans would know as soccer.

    As for the pageants, taken on their own they may not seem like the worst thing ever (unless you’re looking at the most extreme and horrible ones), but taken as part of an overall package that tells girls their value is based on their looks, they are damaging in my opinion. This particular ban in France wasn’t an isolated ban. It was part of a larger legislative project addressing inequality between men and women.

    • Anne Born

      Without thinking, we go out of our way to tell girls their looks matter. They see magazines, they watch movies – in each instance, it’s the pretty slim girl who wins, the smart fat funny girl who loses. What I saw in the pageants I went to was actually affirming the value the girls had beyond their looks. And it was more dress-up than anything else.

      • http://phdinparenting.com Annie @ PhD in Parenting

        Yes, society does go out of its way to tell girls their looks matter over everything else. Some parents, activists, teachers, and other leaders are trying to fight against that and change the paradigm. Films like Miss Representation and Sext Up Kids are important in exposing what is happening. But there is so much more work to do in our homes and in society.

        • Anne Born

          I agree! That’s why this law and others like it are such a waste of energy. Too much rant, too little impact.

  • http://www.alysasalzberg.com Alysa Salzberg

    This was an intriguing read – I never figured you for a pageant mom! But I will say that in France, there’s also another reason that might have motivated the ban: many French people I know consider pageants as a way of sexualizing young girls. Pageants, which are allowed in nearby Belgium, have been featured in several critical news reports here, with that idea in mind. To me, that explanation actually makes more sense for a ban, since, sadly, French culture is so focused on women’s looks that I highly doubt that would have been the only impetus for this law. It’s interesting that it’s being presented that way, though. Thank you for giving me a lot to think about here.

    • Anne Born

      Thanks, Alysa! The pageants I went to, the ones with really young girls competing, had serious limits. You couldn’t watch if you didn’t have a family member in the pageant, there was no swimwear, nothing even remotely sexualizing. Looks is one thing, that sexy stuff is another. I saw in the news that this vote stopped a pageant in Ireland the following week.

kurt cobain rolling stone cover
Rolling Stone Just Put Feminist and Advocate Kurt Cobain on Their UVA Report Cover
Mad Men finale, Mad Men and women
Six Months, 65 Episodes: What I Learned Catching Up With “Mad Men”
105251_0748b_2
Téa Leoni Saves the World
800px-Subway-Restaurant_in_Passau
Eating Subway in France, or How I Finally Learned the Metric System
Hand of an old woman with golden jewelry in hospital bed
Do I Want to Know if I’ll Get Alzheimer’s?
paperwork
In Praise of Taxes
unnamed-1
Trigger Warning: Western Privilege
kurt cobain rolling stone cover
Rolling Stone Just Put Feminist and Advocate Kurt Cobain on Their UVA Report Cover
Equal Pay Day, Paycheck Fairness Act
Equal Pay Day: Even Kids Get It
2006_04_13_Chicago_Speech
Go Ahead, Hillary, Earn My Everyday American Vote
US Department of Defense via Wikimedia Commons
15 Possible Hillary Clinton Campaign Announcements
800px-Надежда
Hillary Clinton to Announce Campaign in 140 Characters?
Huang-sidebar-1
Women in Science: When it Comes to Robotics, It’s Not Just About Ironman
Hand of an old woman with golden jewelry in hospital bed
Do I Want to Know if I’ll Get Alzheimer’s?
paperwork
In Praise of Taxes
crayons
Coloring Books for Adults? Cheaper than Therapy!
Hand of an old woman with golden jewelry in hospital bed
Do I Want to Know if I’ll Get Alzheimer’s?
sexual assault on college campuses, rape on college campuses
Believe Me
women and aging, Frances McDormand, embracing matronly
Why “Matron” Isn’t a Four Letter Word
boston-bomber-cover
Where Is Michael Brown’s ‘Humanizing’ Magazine Cover?
SBEMH-Graphic4
The Space Between Love and Fear
sexual women on TV, sexual role models
Powerful Sexual Female Role Models of a “Certain Age”
reinvention culture, Oprah and reinvention, More Magazine and reinvention, women stop reinventing yourselves
Reinvention Culture is Killing Me
Vintage_Valentine_02
Cupid’s Weekend Cocktails: It Takes Two

Get our new weekly email
Broadly Speaking

featuring our best words for the week + an exclusive longread