Romney’s Binders Full of Women: Inartful Comment or Real World View?

The blogosphere loves a good meme.

Who doesn’t like a little Ryan “Hey Girl” Gosling (especially that feminist Ryan Gosling!) or some bad-ass Texts from Hillary. They’re good fun with a grain a truth — women’s collective love for both the hunky actor and the Secretary of State many of us want to run for president in 2016 are nice diversions in a work day.

But Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney has hit the meme mother lode with his debate response to questions about equal pay and opportunities for women.

In telling his story about his apparent concern for having a gender-balanced cabinet as Massachusetts Governor, Romney claims to have been presented with “binders full” of women’s resumes — that he requested — that he would consider, became more than just an amusing thing to run through the online world for a few days.

He was shocked! Quel surprise! (He did spend time in France, you know). Who knew there would be so many women in the first decade of the 21st century who were more than wives or waitresses or Wal-mart moms!?

Romney’s comment about “binders full of women” summarized the nut of his attitude and world view about working women. This isn’t just about the binders. This is about a man who, in 2003, was amazed and admits that he “learned a great deal” about women, the issues faced by working mothers when he became governor, and how to handle things “if” women were going to be a part of the workforce.

In 2003.

His comments weren’t those of a southern state governor just after Ms. Magazine was launched and feminists burned their bras in the 1970s. His apparent feminist awakening didn’t happen in the decade that the Supreme Court decided Roe v. Wade. This was 21st century Boston, home to a couple of pretty decent colleges with plenty of great women’s minds, like Harvard, MIT, Boston College, and Boston University.

But even in telling of this momentary awakening, Romney didn’t quite get the facts straight. According to a news report, a women’s PAC, seeking more gender equity in state leadership roles, put together said binder, presenting it to their newly elected governor. Romney was pushed to spend some time with those binders of women out of political necessity, not because he had become enlightened about affirmative action or had his eyes opened to the fact that women really can do the same jobs as men!

Want a truer picture of how Romney views the role of working women? Take a look at how many were partners at Bain Capital when he was running it.

None. Zero. Zip.

Why does anyone care? The two candidates must care because women are the majority of voters in America, women vote in larger numbers than men, and women voters have determined the outcome of the last handful of presidential elections. If you’re a candidate who wants to be president, you have to woo and win women voters. And if you have a history of ignoring women, or just paying lip-service to the idea of including women in the full array of work and leadership opportunities in America, that’s not a big selling point if you want women to vote for you.

While President Obama certainly has a few women’s issues of his own — having a cabinet and group of senior advisers infamous for being something of a boys’ club and a reluctance to push for actual equal pay for women (the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act only guarantees workers, both men and women, expanded periods of time to sue for wage discrimination), his outlook on the role of women is more evolved than a 1950s era Romney.

When Romney and his campaign people begin the inevitable walk back of his “shock and awe” moment about qualified women, remember that this is the same man who said in the same debate that our gun violence problem can be traced to single moms and moms who work outside the home, rather than forsaking paid work for full-time care-giving. You can imagine what he’d have to say about those women if they were in his cabinet.

As for the binders themselves, I’d really like to see if they still exist and who was available for him to choose from, and whether he would put them on a short list for a Romney White House.

Plus, I’m just a sucker for good office supplies.

After I wrote this post, I decided to create a “Binders Full of Women” Pinterest page, to celebrate the women whose only binder they needed to be in was their own. Let me know who you think should be “pinned” and celebrated!

Image via iStockphoto

  • http://www.kimcottrell.com Kim

    Well, from watching my relatives lives, it’s apparent there are no women in positions of power in the Mormon church. Therefore, in the world view of a Mormon man, it’s not normal for there to be women in power anywhere in the world.

Jon Stewart, Sanctuary, Animals, racism
Where the Wild Places Are: Jon Stewart Has the Right Idea
Hillary Clinton likability, Hillary likable enough, Donald Trump, 2016 presidential campaign
Hillary Has to be The Girlfriend, but “The Donald” Can be The Grinch
E.L. Doctorow, George W. Bush
In Praise Of E.L. Doctorow: The Man Who Looked Into GWB’s Eyes and Saw Nothing
Google fiber, high speed internet
I’m Dreaming of an Ultra-Fast Christmas … in July
College suicide, mother's response to New York Times on Campus suicide
A Mother’s Response to The New York Times: Campus Suicide is More Complicated Than You Think
IMG_2603
Flat Francis: Spending a Day with the Pope in New York
passing as white, passing as black, Rachel Dolezal, white woman identifying as black
Little White Lies: Can You Choose Your Race?
Hillary Clinton likability, Hillary likable enough, Donald Trump, 2016 presidential campaign
Hillary Has to be The Girlfriend, but “The Donald” Can be The Grinch
BlogHer BlackLivesMatter
BlogHer Nails What Netroots Nation Fails: #BlackLivesMatter
Hillary Clinton likability, Hillary likable enough, Donald Trump, 2016 presidential campaign
Hillary Has to be The Girlfriend, but “The Donald” Can be The Grinch
E.L. Doctorow, George W. Bush
In Praise Of E.L. Doctorow: The Man Who Looked Into GWB’s Eyes and Saw Nothing
Jimmy Carter, Jimmy Carter book, A Full Life: Reflections at Ninety, naming a child for a president
We Named Our Son After Jimmy Carter
College suicide, mother's response to New York Times on Campus suicide
A Mother’s Response to The New York Times: Campus Suicide is More Complicated Than You Think
Jon Stewart, Sanctuary, Animals, racism
Where the Wild Places Are: Jon Stewart Has the Right Idea
Hillary Clinton likability, Hillary likable enough, Donald Trump, 2016 presidential campaign
Hillary Has to be The Girlfriend, but “The Donald” Can be The Grinch
E.L. Doctorow, George W. Bush
In Praise Of E.L. Doctorow: The Man Who Looked Into GWB’s Eyes and Saw Nothing
dying friends, friendship and death, denial about friend's death
Could I Have Been a Better Friend at the End?
women's lives, planning for the unexpected, Chinese adoption
Cushioning My Landing: When Emotions Collide with Rationality
11069864_385264318326651_7985163416737673298_n
A New York City Feminist on the Camino de Santiago
white people talking about race
Just a White Girl From the Suburbs
marriage equality and Supreme Court, history of gay rights in America
Let’s Celebrate the Supreme Court Decision on Marriage Equality, But Let’s Not Forget the History That Got Us Here
Magic Mike XXL, women's erotica, Women's sex lives, women's fantasies, male gaze, female gaze, feminist and Magic Mike
Magic Mike XXL: Male Strippers, Women’s Fantasies and Why We Should Stop Judging Each Other
National Kissing Day
The Science of Kissing
women's viagra, Viagra, Flibanserin, sexual arousal, women's desire, sex after menopause
That “Little Pink Pill” Isn’t All It’s Cracked Up to Be

Get our new weekly email
Broadly Speaking

featuring our best words for the week + an exclusive longread