Ryan White, Part Deux

Founders Hall, Milton Hershey School, courtesy of http://www.mhs-pa.org

Milton and  Catherine Hershey had a vision.  Their vision was realized in the Milton Hershey School, to “nurture and educate children in social and financial need to lead fulfilling and productive lives.  To that end, the Milton Hershey School in Pennsylvania has provided thousands of under-served and underprivileged children a stellar education free of charge since 1909.

Today, that image and vision has been tarnished.

The Milton Hershey School has denied admission to a “Abraham Smith” (pseudonym), a 13-year-old ambitious, but economically disadvantaged, honor student, solely based on the fact that he has HIV. In Abraham’s own words, he says what started as hope for admission and the future, ” has turned into fear, anger, confusion and tears.

No child should have to face that type of discrimination and confusion.  In fact, Ryan White, a middle school student expelled from school in the mid-1980’s because he had HIV, paved the way so that no other child would have to face such discrimination.

So, how can the Milton Hershey School justify its action to deny this student admission to their institution?  They do this by stating that they feel that “Abraham Smith” poses a “direct threat” to the health and well-being of the other students they serve.

A direct threat.

The statement goes on to say that the main reason that they denied him was that their school is a “unique” institution, in that, the children live in houses of 10 to 12 students with a married couple serving as house parents.  Their reasoning is that “ our teenagers are the same as teens all across the country. Despite our best efforts, some of our students will engage in sexual activity with one another.”

It is enough to make you wonder what kind of control they have after hours in their own boarding houses.

By their own admission, the administrators at the Milton Hershey School denied “Abraham Smith” on the speculation that he may have sex while at the school.  In addition, they assume that the sex that he may or may not have may be unprotected sex.  Finally, they know, by their own admission, that while “Abraham Smith” is on medication, the chance of him passing HIV to another student, assuming that he has unprotected sex, is as little as a 4% chance of infection.

A direct threat?

The law is very clear on this situation.  According to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) file on HIV/AIDS, those with HIV have a covered disability.  Furthermore, public accommodations, which covers private entities such as private schools, cannot claim that they are refusing to provide accommodations because that person allegedly poses a direct threat to others.  Specifically, when asked if a public accommodation can exclude a person with HIV under the assumption that the person poses a direct threat, the ADA responds, ” In almost every instance, the answer to this question is no. Persons with HIV/AIDS will rarely, if ever, pose a direct threat in the public accommodations context.” 

Additionally, the ADA statement  on HIV goes on to include scenarios where public accommodations cannot be denied to those with the HIV virus:

“A public accommodation may exclude an individual with a

disability from participation in an activity, if that

individual’s participation would result in a direct threat to the

health or safety of others.  “Direct threat,” however, is defined

as a “significant risk to the health or safety of others” that

cannot be eliminated or reduced to an acceptable level by

reasonable modifications to the public accommodation s policies,

practices, or procedures, or by the provision of appropriate

auxiliary aids or services.  The determination that a person

poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others may not

be based on generalizations or stereotypes about the effects of a

particular disability; it must be based on an individual

assessment that considers the particular activity and the actual

abilities and disabilities of the individual.  The individual

assessment must be based on reasonable judgment that relies on

current medical evidence.

For example:

…… A day care center’s refusal to admit a child who is

HIV-positive, because of the fear that the child might bite and

might therefore transmit HIV to other children, is also a

violation.  It is incorrect to assume that all young children bite.”

Consequently, how is this day care situation provided by the ADA any different than the situation with “Abraham Smith”?  We cannot assume that “Abraham Smith” will have unprotected sex while attending the Milton Hershey school, therefore the school cannot discriminate because their fear that he may engage in unprotected sex.  Furthermore, we cannot assume that all teens make the poor decision to have unprotected sex, just like we cannot assume that all young children bite.  In their own statement, Milton Hershey School states that SOME of the students may have unprotected sex with each other.  It is under this “fact” they felt denying “Abraham Smith” admission was justified.

Unfortunately, “Abraham Smith”, a child, is now a happenstance participant in the next civil rights fight concerning those with HIV.  The AIDS Project of Pennsylvania has filed a suit against the school on behalf of “Smith.”  Despite their best efforts, however, “Smith’s” life will never be the same.  The discrimination he has faced at the hands of the Milton Hershey School has no doubt caused significant damage to his feeling of self-worth.

And for that alone, the Milton Hershey School should be ashamed.

  • Tamar

    I’m amazed not only by how impoverished morally these school administrators are, but also at how stupid they must be. This is the kind of case that will permanently damage the school’s reputation.
    Based on their speculation,they should not admit any teenagers since “some of our teens will engage in sexual activity with one another” and that can lead to pregnancy or STDs other than HIV. Do they test every single child for Chlamydia, Herpes, Syphilis and Gonorrhea? Gee — what if a child has cold sores in their mouth (caused by herpes) — they might, just might, engage in oral sex and pass that on to another child (or kiss for that matter).

  • http://www.dirtandnoise.com/ IlinaP

    It’s a good thing stupidity isn’t contagious.

kurt cobain rolling stone cover
Rolling Stone Just Put Feminist and Advocate Kurt Cobain on Their UVA Report Cover
Mad Men finale, Mad Men and women
Six Months, 65 Episodes: What I Learned Catching Up With “Mad Men”
Téa Leoni Saves the World
Eating Subway in France, or How I Finally Learned the Metric System
Hand of an old woman with golden jewelry in hospital bed
Do I Want to Know if I’ll Get Alzheimer’s?
In Praise of Taxes
Trigger Warning: Western Privilege
kurt cobain rolling stone cover
Rolling Stone Just Put Feminist and Advocate Kurt Cobain on Their UVA Report Cover
My Political Fantasy: Janet Huckabee Takes on Bill Clinton
Equal Pay Day, Paycheck Fairness Act
Equal Pay Day: Even Kids Get It
Go Ahead, Hillary, Earn My Everyday American Vote
US Department of Defense via Wikimedia Commons
15 Possible Hillary Clinton Campaign Announcements
feeling fat
Is Fat Passé?
Women in Science: When it Comes to Robotics, It’s Not Just About Ironman
Hand of an old woman with golden jewelry in hospital bed
Do I Want to Know if I’ll Get Alzheimer’s?
In Praise of Taxes
Hand of an old woman with golden jewelry in hospital bed
Do I Want to Know if I’ll Get Alzheimer’s?
sexual assault on college campuses, rape on college campuses
Believe Me
women and aging, Frances McDormand, embracing matronly
Why “Matron” Isn’t a Four Letter Word
Where Is Michael Brown’s ‘Humanizing’ Magazine Cover?
The Space Between Love and Fear
sexual women on TV, sexual role models
Powerful Sexual Female Role Models of a “Certain Age”
reinvention culture, Oprah and reinvention, More Magazine and reinvention, women stop reinventing yourselves
Reinvention Culture is Killing Me
Cupid’s Weekend Cocktails: It Takes Two

Get our new weekly email
Broadly Speaking

featuring our best words for the week + an exclusive longread